\subsection{Number representation and C implementation} \label{subsec:num-repr-rfc} As described in \sref{subsec:Number-TweetNaCl}, numbers in \TNaCle{gf} are represented in $2^{16}$ and we use a direct mapping to represent that array as a list integers in Coq. However, in order to show the correctness of the basic operations, we need to convert this number to an integer. We reuse the mapping $\text{\coqe{ZofList}} : \Z \rightarrow \texttt{list}~\Z \rightarrow \Z$ from \sref{sec:Coq-RFC} and define a notation where $n$ is $16$, placing us with a radix of $2^{16}$. \begin{lstlisting}[language=Coq] Notation "Z16.lst A" := (ZofList 16 A). \end{lstlisting} To facilitate working in $\Zfield$, we define the \coqe{:GF} notation. \begin{lstlisting}[language=Coq] Notation "A :GF" := (A mod (2^255-19)). \end{lstlisting} Later in \sref{subsec:Zmodp}, we formally define $\Ffield$ as a field. Equivalence between operations in $\Zfield$ (\ie under \coqe{:GF}) and in $\Ffield$ are easily proven. Using these two definitions, we prove intermediate lemmas such as the correctness of the multiplication \Coqe{Low.M} where \Coqe{Low.M} replicates the computations and steps done in C. \begin{lemma} \label{lemma:mult_correct} \Coqe{Low.M} correctly implements the multiplication over $\Zfield$. \end{lemma} And specified in Coq as follows: \begin{lstlisting}[language=Coq] Lemma mult_GF_Zlength : forall (a:list Z) (b:list Z), Zlength a = 16 -> Zlength b = 16 -> (Z16.lst (Low.M a b)) :GF = (Z16.lst a * Z16.lst b) :GF. \end{lstlisting} However for our purpose, simple functional correctness is not enough. We also need to define the bounds under which the operation is correct, allowing us to chain them, guaranteeing us the absence of overflow. \begin{lemma} \label{lemma:mult_bounded} if all the values of the input arrays are constrained between $-2^{26}$ and $2^{26}$, then the output of \coqe{Low.M} will be constrained between $-38$ and $2^{16} + 38$. \end{lemma} And seen in Coq as follows: \begin{lstlisting}[language=Coq] Lemma M_bound_Zlength : forall (a:list Z) (b:list Z), Zlength a = 16 -> Zlength b = 16 -> Forall (fun x => -2^26 < x < 2^26) a -> Forall (fun x => -2^26 < x < 2^26) b -> Forall (fun x => -38 <= x < 2^16 + 38) (Low.M a b). \end{lstlisting}